Skip links

The Sticky Strategy of the Lock-In Business Model

Have you ever wondered why some companies seem to have your loyalty no matter what – even when there are competitively priced or even free alternatives available?

These companies have mastered the art of the lock-in business model.

What is a Lock-In Business Model?

A lock-in business model refers to companies that employ tactics to get customers “stuck” using their products or services, making it frictionless to stay while adding speed bumps to leave.

On the surface, this may seem underhanded. But used judiciously, lock-in strategies allow companies to recoup heavy early-stage investments required to acquire users and provide confidence to keep improving their offerings.

The best lock-ins align company and customer interests for a win-win.

Lock-ins inhibit choice in the short term but can supercharge innovation over the long term.

Just look at the explosion of creativity coming from Apple’s walled garden app ecosystem. By tying developers to iOS, they’ve created the world’s most vibrant developer community.

How Do Lock-in Business Models Work?

Brand loyalty driven by superior user experience is one form of lock-in. But many companies employ more tactical approaches as well:

High Switching Costs

Every time you send a Word doc instead of a Google Doc link, you are creating switching costs for the recipient. Once Microsoft products permeate an enterprise environment, it becomes extremely expensive to migrate away.

Data & Workflows

The more data a company accumulates on you and the more they customize for your habits, the harder it is to leave without losing access or efficiency. Think Amazon e-commerce preferences or iOS vs Android text threads.

Habit Formation

Human beings are creatures of habit. Uber’s fantastic user experience practically trains you to stop thinking about other rideshare options. Their ample driver supply in most areas removes the incentive to even compare.

Contractual Commitments

Gyms are notorious for requiring long-term contracts to join. This guarantees income and means leaving requires planning months in advance. Cell phone plans often employ early termination fees as well for similar reasons.

Real-Life Examples of Lock-in Business Models

Lock-in tactics are everywhere once you start looking. Here are some prime examples across – tech, transportation, and entertainment sectors.

Apple’s Ecosystem

Over 1 billion active iPhones globally give Apple an enviable scale. But their lock-in secret sauce goes deeper.

AirPods enhance the user experience. iMessage and iTunes keep communications and content constrained. App Store vetting enables security and customization. Switching means physically replacing hardware but also losing these deep integrations.

Amazon Prime

A masterclass in lock-in techniques. Prime subs get used to free fast delivery and binge-watching videos. Meanwhile, Amazon collects massive data on behavior and secures recurring subscription revenue.

New services like pharmacy and grocery delivery further embed customers into reliable habits. What began as a bookseller now anchors consumer lifestyles.

Microsoft Office

1.2 billion global users interact in doc file formats that originate from Office. Enterprise reliance on Excel and Outlook workflows. Microsoft’s position seems unassailable, but they are aggressively layering on new lock-ins like Teams messaging to maintain dominance.


600 million members have invested serious time in building professional profiles and connections. Leaving means losing access to critical business relationships.

Additionally, features like job matching get better with scale. These factors secure LinkedIn as the defacto professional social network despite minimal innovation.

Satellite TV

In an era of cord-cutting and streaming TV, old-school satellite providers like DIRECTV still retain millions of subscribers. Their long-term contracts guarantee income, while exclusive premium content like NFL Sunday Ticket provides differentiation. Not easy to walk away from your favorite sports team.

Hotel Rewards

Loyalty programs cleverly prey on human psychology. Trees don’t grow to the sky, yet points and status tiers trick us into overvaluing future benefits compared to present savings.

Once enough points are accumulated, it feels sub-optimal to redeem them anywhere but that hotel chain.

Enabling Innovation Through Lock-in

Lock-in business models provide the stability for companies to confidently invest in risky, long-term innovations. Some examples:


Apple’s computing ecosystem set the foundation for iPhone development. Software and hardware designed in tandem unlocked capabilities competitors still struggle to match.

AWS Cloud

By dominating early cloud infrastructure, Amazon could fund an army of engineers to power ahead with no assurance of payback except for their existing base sticking around.

Netflix Originals

Big data insights on subscriber watching habits gave Netflix confidence to earmark $17 billion a year in creating original films and series. This focus on exclusive content helps retain their 220 million global viewer base.

The Nuances of Good vs Bad Lock-ins

Implementing sticky lock-ins is an art – going overboard risks consumer backlash. Here are some best practices startups should consider:

  • Provide Transparency – clearly communicate terms like subscriptions or termination policies so users understand commitment expectations. No dark patterns.
  • Offer a Fair Deal – whether pricing, contract length, or data policies, excessive lock-ins will get called out in app store reviews or public forums.
  • Make it Reciprocal – users accept restrictions on choice when there is symmetrical value. Data insights that improve the product experience or provide premium features that tangibly enhance lives.
  • Build Trust Daily – companies focused solely on lock-in tactics without sustaining trust betray their users. Consistently under-delivering on support, quality or experience erodes permission to maintain lock-in over the long term.

The Future of Lock-ins

Expect more experimentation with sticky business models even in traditional categories immune to platform dynamics. Every startup now assesses lock-in potential early in their strategy.

Incumbents will bolster their defenses as well. More value is bundled into existing subscriptions across entertainment, physical goods, transportation, and software. Integration mergers will target adjacent categories possessing complementary lock-ins. Think Microsoft acquiring Activision Blizzard to evolve gaming ecosystem dynamics.

Finally, regulators may look to stimulate competition through interoperability mandates. Imagine if you could migrate your highly personalized TikTok “FYP” feed to other social apps or access iMessage communities outside iOS.

With platforms like Shopify and Snapchat now commanding decade-long loyalty spans, the lesson is clear. Lock-in drives predictable growth. Identify and secure your unfair advantages before someone else does!

Related Posts

Leave a comment